Middletown’s Football Fight Reaches a Critical Hearing: Where the Case Stands

UPDATED: Middletown withdrew its Article 78 application and petition during the November 13 hearing. This report documents the arguments made before withdrawal and the circumstances surrounding the eligibility dispute.

EDITOR’S UPDATE — NOVEMBER 19: Middletown withdrew its Article 78 application and petition at the November 13 court hearing. The emergency request is no longer pending. This article was published before that hearing and the original reporting is retained below as a record of the arguments made at the time. For the later outcome and timeline, see KOT845’s full case chronology.

The district admits an eligibility mistake but argues its players should not lose their championship opportunity. The athletic associations say the forfeiture must stand. Friday’s court appearance will put those competing positions before a judge.

By KOT845 Media | November 13, 2026 | Pre-hearing report. Court status last independently checked at 11:44 a.m. EST.

Middletown’s football team won 10 games on the field. Continuing its season now depends on obtaining court relief from the eligibility determination that removed it from the Section IX championship. The district is asking an Orange County Supreme Court judge to restore its opportunity to compete against Newburgh on Saturday, November 14.

Justice Verris B. Shako scheduled a 2 p.m. appearance Friday, November 13, to hear the emergency application. The signed Order to Show Cause brought the dispute before the court, but did not reinstate Middletown: the proposed provisions granting immediate relief were crossed out.

At KOT845’s 11:44 a.m. check, the public NYSCEF docket ended at Document #38. No newer order granting a temporary restraining order or restoring Middletown’s eligibility was listed. A subsequent pre-publication browser check encountered a CAPTCHA challenge, so KOT845 could not independently check any later entries in that session. The court-status statements in this report are limited to the last successful check.

The distinction matters. Middletown secured a hearing—not a return to the championship.

Court records: NYSCEF Document #1, prayer for relief; Document #2, November 9 letter; and signed Document #13, pages 2–3. Official docket: EF012752-2026.

The violation is admitted. The consequences are contested.

The dispute involves a soccer player who joined Middletown’s football program as a kickoff specialist and participated in its November 6 sectional semifinal against Valley Central. Middletown’s petition acknowledges that the athlete did not satisfy the football representation requirement for sectional competition.

The practice requirement and the representation requirement are separate. Completing the required practices does not, by itself, establish eligibility for sectional competition. The filed handbook states that football athletes must have been eligible participants for a minimum of three contests; the district’s petition acknowledges that the player fell short.

Middletown is therefore not principally asking the court to find that the player met the rule. It is challenging the denial of relief and the resulting loss of the team’s championship opportunity.

“The District does not dispute that it violated NYSPHSAA’s Eligibility Standard 26(a),” the petition states, before arguing that denying its waiver request unfairly imposed the consequences of an adult administrative error on the students. That is Middletown’s legal position, not a finding by the court.

Sources: petition, Document #1, paragraphs 23–30 and 39–40; handbook, Document #3, pages 47–48.

Middletown’s argument: hold the adults accountable without ending the students’ season

Superintendent Amy Creeden’s sworn affidavit accepts district responsibility for failing to identify the eligibility problem and states that the student-athletes did not contribute to the error. The district argues that losing the championship opportunity would cause harm that could not meaningfully be repaired after the season, particularly for seniors.

Its proposed alternatives include keeping the kicker out of further competition, imposing a financial sanction on the district, requiring outside eligibility training, and having the district cover championship officials’ fees. Middletown also proposed written approval for athletes moving between sports and a second administrator’s source review of postseason eligibility. These are proposed remedies and safeguards—not measures the court has ordered.

The district’s filing includes community letters and a screenshot of a petition seeking to reverse the decision. Those materials illustrate the public response and the concerns families have expressed about the students’ lost opportunity; they do not establish that the eligibility determination was unlawful.

Even NYSPHSAA Executive Director Robert Zayas’s November 9 denial acknowledged that the students were not responsible for the administrative oversight. But his letter maintained that sympathy for their circumstances did not authorize him to waive an established eligibility standard.

Sources: Document #7, Creeden affidavit, paragraphs 4–10; Document #4, self-report, pages 2–3; Documents #9–10, supporting letters and petition screenshot; Document #2, Zayas letter.

Why the opposition says the forfeiture must stand

The central obstacle for Middletown is the handbook’s tournament-forfeiture provision.

Rule 19(b) states that an ineligible player’s participation in a sectional tournament game results in forfeiture, immediate disqualification, and advancement of the team’s last opponent. The provision does not make those consequences depend on the player’s position, how long he played, or whether intentional cheating occurred.

In its opposition memorandum, NYSPHSAA argues that the rule cannot be replaced with a lesser penalty based on an assertion that the kicker did not affect the outcome. Its attorney, Renee L. James, also argues that a representation waiver must be requested before sectional participation and cannot be granted retroactively.

Valley Central has its own direct interest. Attorney Daniel Petigrow argues that the forfeiture rule requires Valley Central to advance and that Middletown has not established grounds for a waiver. Reinstating Middletown would replace Valley Central in the championship—not simply remove a punishment without affecting another team.

These remain the respondents’ arguments. The court has not adopted them as findings in the materials reviewed for this report.

Sources: handbook, Document #3, page 44; NYSPHSAA opposition memorandum, Document #25, page 6; Valley Central opposition affirmation, Document #26, paragraphs 6–10.

The waiver question is more complicated than “there are no exceptions”

Middletown’s petition expressly relies on the handbook’s nonmedical, extenuating-circumstances waiver provision. That provision gives the NYSPHSAA executive director authority to grant a representation waiver in consultation with the Section executive director and NYSPHSAA president. It requires a written request from the Section executive director.

Creeden specifically asked Section IX Executive Director Gregory Ransom to submit such a request. Ransom’s November 8 response said he had no option but to declare the semifinal a forfeit and had forwarded the district’s appeal to Zayas.

Zayas’s denial, however, explained the result broadly in terms of limits on his authority. It did not expressly address why the particular extenuating-circumstances provision was unavailable. NYSPHSAA’s subsequent court memorandum supplies a more specific position: the request came too late, and the circumstances would not justify that waiver.

That leaves an important issue for the proceeding: how the waiver provision applies to this request after the semifinal had already been played. The existence of waiver language does not automatically establish that Middletown qualified for relief or that an already-incurred forfeiture could be undone.

A separate provision, Rule 19(f), permits a district to seek relief from a prescribed penalty when the violation resulted from circumstances outside the district’s control. Its wording is narrower than saying the students were not responsible. Middletown’s own affidavit accepts district responsibility for the mistake.

Sources: Document #1, paragraph 35; handbook, Document #3, pages 44 and 48; Document #5, November 8 email exchange; Document #2, Zayas denial; Document #25, page 6; Document #7, paragraph 5.

The evidence leaves questions about how the mistake happened

NYSPHSAA’s memorandum asserts that Middletown’s athletic director attended September training covering eligibility and penalties. The workshop excerpt supplied as Exhibit B includes a representation slide stating the three-contest minimum, but that particular slide does not expressly explain its application to postseason eligibility or the forfeiture consequence. The excerpt also does not establish everything explained orally or elsewhere in the workshop.

The district’s documents also contain a discrepancy in the athlete’s eligibility timeline. Its November 8 self-report says he completed the practice requirement by October 23 and was eligible for two regular-season contests. The November 11 petition says he completed the requirement around October 29 and was eligible for one. Both accounts fall short of three, but the reviewed documents do not explain the change.

Meanwhile, the petition’s account of administrative oversight does not set out the detailed eligibility advice exchanged among coaches and administrators before the athlete played. That remains a separate factual question from the district’s acknowledgment that a violation occurred.

Sources: Document #25, page 7; workshop excerpt, Document #29, page 7; Document #4, pages 1–2; Document #1, paragraphs 25–32.

What Friday’s appearance will involve

Court directions filed Friday clarify that the appearance has in-person requirements, despite requests for virtual participation.

Section IX’s Ransom may appear virtually, but attorney Stephanie M. Roebuck must be in the courtroom. Middletown’s lead attorney, Kate I. Reid, may observe virtually, but an attorney for the district must attend in person and make its arguments. The court’s directions do not identify which Middletown attorney will do so.

Valley Central has also asked the judge to consider Theresa Uhelsky’s affidavit and supporting exhibits filed after the court’s 9:30 a.m. opposition deadline. In Document #38, Petigrow attributes the delay to a Microsoft service outage and says Reid does not object to the request. That letter does not itself establish that the court accepted the late submissions.

The broader case is an Article 78 proceeding. CPLR 7803(3) permits review of decisions for unlawful procedure, errors of law, arbitrary or capricious action, and abuse of discretion, including concerning a penalty. The question is therefore not simply whether the result feels harsh, but whether there is a legally sufficient basis to disturb it.

As of the last docket check, the position was straightforward: Middletown was seeking emergency relief, the forfeiture was being defended, and no new order restoring its championship place had been identified.

The November 13 appearance at 2 p.m. remained the next scheduled step in the reviewed court record. Its outcome must be established by what the court actually directs—not by the language a party requested, a filing’s processing status, or speculation about which side is winning.

Sources: court directions, Documents #36–37; Valley Central’s letter, Document #38; signed Order to Show Cause, Document #13, page 3.


Further reporting: Read KOT845’s original investigation and chronological court updates. Consult the official NYSCEF docket for the filings identified above.

Editor’s disclosure: KOT845 founder Isaac Cayetano is an assistant coach with Middletown’s football program. This report is based on the court filings, supplied exhibits and public docket. Statements made by litigants are attributed as their positions, not presented as judicial findings. Times are Eastern Standard Time.

KOT845 Community

Join the Conversation

Keep it respectful and focused on the story. First-time comments may be held for moderation.

Add Your Take

Your email will not be published. Keep criticism about programs and decisions — not personal attacks on students.

About the Author

Isaac Cayetano

Founder & Editor-in-Chief, Kings of the 845

Isaac Cayetano is the Founder and Editor-in-Chief of Kings of the 845 (KOT845), covering Section IX football, basketball, rankings, community stories, and Hudson Valley sports culture. A football coach and longtime Section IX analyst, Isaac founded KOT845 in 2020 to create the Hudson Valley's premier sports and community media platform.

View All Articles by Isaac Cayetano →
KOT845 Newsletter

The 845,
Delivered.

Get Section IX football, fall sports and basketball coverage, rankings, recruiting updates, event announcements, community stories and select partner offers sent directly to your inbox.


Subscriber information is handled according to the KOT845 Privacy Policy.

Your watchlist

KOT845

Share this page

X / TwitterWhatsAppFacebookEmail

Share to apps opens the options available on your device. You can also copy the link into any app.

Make a share image

Download this image for Instagram or another app. Long features have multiple images; choose the image below. For a Story, add a link sticker.

Download image